This will be my first review of a short story collection here on the blog and it makes me happy that it is a Neil Gaiman collection. My first Neil Gaiman book bought with my own money was Smoke and Mirrors and with the announcement of the ultimate collection of Neil Gaiman short stories being published in the next year I felt it was time to read the others again.
Trigger Warning collects a series of tales that include a previously unpublished American Gods novella, Black Dog, a story of a cave that rewards gold at a price, a Doctor Who story following the Doctor and Amy Pond and a tale of 2 colliding fairy tales with a Queen saving a princess. The title itself, discussed by Gaiman in the opening, describes the use of trigger warning sin modern internet usage and how we should or should not have them on books and stories.
So this is going to be a bit of a smaller, more rambling review due to the fact it is a short story collection and it is my first time reviewing one properly. So obviously with collections and anthologies you are going to get stories you liked and those you did not. This book overall I must say had a quite a varied selection of tales that were all mostly enjoyable, bordering the strange gap between horror and fantasy.
One such tale I really enjoyed was ‘Orange’ which from my first read of the book that I never finished in 2016 was one that I remembered very vividly. The story follows a girl making a report of her sister who was very fond of fake tan and the ridiculous level it escalated to. As someone who grew up with a sister who wears fake tan while I utterly HATE the stuff, I found it very entertaining.
Other stories see the return of characters we would know from Gaiman’s other work and figures of popular culture, such as the previously mentioned Doctor, Sherlock Holmes and Shadow Moon. It was so good to read another story set after American Gods and following Shadow. I do love finding out what he is up to. However the Sherlock Holmes story ‘The Case of Death and Honey’ I thought was a bit too long for a Holmes story and it wasn’t really all that interesting come the ending either.
Despite the longer tales feeling like they padded the book slightly, I still enjoyed them most of all particularly The Truth is a Cave in the Black Mountains. Published as a standalone illustrated work, I hadn’t actually read it until this book but it is definitely a stand out tale of vengeance and pain in the Scottish Highlands. I also want Peter Dinklage to play the lead.
As always I warn people, I am a massive Neil Gaiman fan and I will always be biased towards his work but as much as a I enjoyed this volume of short stories I do think it is one of the weaker collections he has released. It is still a great collection of tales but I have preferred others more.
If this review rambles a lot, I do apologise a since I have never reviewed s short story collection before but will be doing far more of in the future. Did you read this?What’s your favourite tale? Do tell me so we can fan-girl over them.